Wednesday, 24 April 2013

(ASA) Case Study of Existing Advertising Campaigns researching the role and impact of - Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) and Ofcom.

What is the background of the ASA?

In 1961 ASA formed along with Committee of Advertising Practice (CAP) to focus on the consumer protection and the public's interest.

Prior to this, regulation of non-broadcast advertising was conducted by the self-regulatory CAP/ASA system and broadcast advertising was regulated separately by a statutory regulator, Ofcom. This change simplified regulation for consumers and business and meant that, for the first time, decisions about ad campaigns running across several media platforms e.g. TV, poster and radio, were made by a single organisation.
(http://www.asa.org.uk/About-ASA/About-regulation/Co-regulation-of-broadcast-advertising.aspx)


What is the role of the ASA in the regulation of advertisements?

In order to handle complaints against adverts, and to avoid the imposition of legislation, the advertising industry set up an independent organisation, the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA), in 1962.

This self-regulatory body has been working hard ever since to make sure that adverts are suitabl;e for the audience they are aimed at. Between 2007 and 2008 it received 24,192 complaints about a record 14,080 advertisements.
(http://www.computeractive.co.uk/ca/pc-help/1912255/the-role-advertising-standards-authority)

The types of adverts they regulate are any adverts that appear in;
-newspapers, -magazines,
-brochures,
-leaflets,
-e-mails,
-text transmissions (including SMS and MMS),
-fax transmissions,
-catalogues,
-follow-up literature,
-cinema,
-video,
-DVD,-etc...

These are examples of adverts they do not regulate;
-Marketing communications in foreign media,
-Works of art exhibited (public or private),
-Statutory, public, police and other official notices or information,
-Claims, addressed only to medical, dental, veterinary or allied practitioners,
-Classified private advertisements
(http://www.cap.org.uk/Advertising-Codes/Non-broadcast-HTML/Scope-of-the-non-broadcast-CAP-code.aspx)


What is the legal standing of the ASA in relation to Ofcom?

The majority of sanctions for non-broadcast advertising are co-ordinated through CAP, whose members are trade associations representing advertisers, agencies and media. There are several CAP sanctions, which can be employed in different circumstances:

-Ad Alerts - CAP can issue alerts to its members, including the media, advising them to withhold services such as access to advertising space.
-Withdrawal of trading privileges - CAP members can revoke, withdraw or temporarily withhold recognition and trading privileges. For example, the Royal Mail can withdraw its bulk mail discount, which can make running direct marketing campaigns prohibitively expensive.
-Pre-vetting - Persistent or serious offenders can be required to have their marketing material vetted before publication. For example, CAP’s poster industry members can invoke mandatory pre-vetting for advertisers who have broken the CAP Code on grounds of taste and decency or social responsibility – the pre-vetting can last for two years.
-Sanctions in the online space - CAP has further sanctions that can be invoked to help ensure marketers’ claims on their own websites, or in other non-paid-for space under their control, comply with the Codes.

If there are any misleading or unfair adeverts, the ASA has the power to refuse rthe advert the right to be shown, unless that advert is changed to be fair.
(http://www.asa.org.uk/Industry-advertisers/Sanctions/Non-broadcast.aspx)


What are the procedures of the organisation?

If someone wants to make an complaint they can fill out an online form.This is the process they have to go through to make their complaint;

-First, check whether your complaint is covered by the ASA. 
-If it is, submit your complaint online, or telephone,text , or write to us.
-We’ll give you the name of the person who will handle the case and be your point of contact.
-The names of those who make a complaint are kept confidential from the advertiser, unless you are asking us to have your name taken off a mailing list or the complaint is from an individual, competitor or organisation with obvious interest in the outcome of the complaint (such as consumer bodies and pressure groups).
-We publish our rulings
-Ads that break the rules are required to be amended or withdrawn, if they aren't  we will take steps to make sure our ruling is followed.

The ASA council judge both non-broadcast and broadcast advertisements. They judge adverts by using UK Code of Broadcast Advertising created by CAP and enforced by ASA.
(http://www.asa.org.uk/Consumers/How-to-complain.aspx)


The ASA also regulate adverts by conducting surveys of advertisements published by secors where there is an unsatisfactory complaince with the codes. And together they work with the CAP to support the industry to help them get their ads right before they are published. 
(http://www.asa.org.uk/About-ASA/About-regulation.aspx)


What are the key parts of the code governing food and soft drink advertising and children and advertising that you think will be important to bare in mind for your advert?

When thinking about making my advert, i will consider any acts that children could copy that may be dangerous or unnacceptable. I will aslo bare in mind false advertising, for example, not telling my audience something that could be taken as an offence or not be true about my product. I will also look into harmful; an offensive acts, such as swearing, sexual references, disturbing scenes or again anythingbad that a child will copy.


Summarise some TV Advertising case studies of problemtic food and soft drink advertising and children and advertising with video embeds and the ASA ruling.

Not Upheld;



A TV ad for Diet Coke showed the singer Duffy coming off stage. An assistant handed her a can of Diet Coke and said "You've got about two minutes okay?" Duffy took a sip of coke, climbed onto a bicycle and cycled through the night along quiet streets and into a supermarket. As she cycled she sang, people she cycled past joined in the song. She returned to the concert in time to perform her encore. The on-screen text stated "hello you".

People complained about this advert for two reasons;

1. 18 viewers challenged whether the ad could be seen to condone behaviour prejudicial to health and safety, because Duffy was not wearing reflective clothing and did not have lights on her bicycle.
2. 4 viewers challenged whether the ad was irresponsible because it risked emulation by children.

This advert was not upheld because;

1. Coca-Cola Great Britain (Coca-Cola) said the ad was not meant to reflect reality.  They said it was meant to be Duffy's fantasy, a scenario that depicted her escape from the pressures of stardom and far removed from the real world.  They said they wanted to show her taking that journey in a way that would not be possible in real life.
2. Coca-Cola said they would not target any marketing of any of their drinks to children under the age of 12 years. They said the ad did not risk emulation by children because the content and tone of the ad was targeted primarily at a female audience aged 20 and upwards.


Partially Upheld;



A TV ad, for Maltesers, showed two men and two women sitting on a sofa. The men were asleep while the women were watching TV. One woman, who was eating Maltesers, offered the bag to her friend and said "Want one?" As she took a Malteser, the friend said "Oh go on then, naughty". The woman replied "Less than 11 calories each"; on-screen text stated "per 2.1g sweet". The other woman looked a bit disappointed and said "Yeah? That's not very naughty". The two women then rearranged the sleeping men on the sofa so that they were cuddling and giggled as they watched the men snuggling up to each other. A voice-over stated "Maltesers. At less than 11 calories each, you'll need new ways to be naughty". The ad then showed Maltesers floating in the air and wearing haloes. On-screen text stated "Maltesers THE LIGHTER WAY TO ENJOY CHOCOLATE".

This advert was complaiend about for two reasons;

1. One viewer, a Food Safety & Standards Officer, challenged whether the claim "less than 11 calories each" misleadingly implied Maltesers were a low energy product.

2. The ASA challenged whether the claim "THE LIGHTER WAY TO ENJOY CHOCOLATE" misleadingly suggested Maltesers were lower in energy than other similar products.

The ASA found a way to sort out the advert;

1. Mars argued that, under the transitional provisions of the Regulation, it was permissible to continue to use nutrition claims not listed in the Regulations Annex until January 2010, providing the claim had been used prior to 1 January 2006.  They said the claim "less than (X) calories" was not listed in the Annex to the Regulation and such a claim had been used by at least one of their competitors before 1 January 2006. They therefore argued that, even if the claim "less than 11 calories each" was held to be a nutrition claim, it could be used in accordance with the Regulation until January 2010.

2. Mars said the claim "THE LIGHTER WAY TO ENJOY CHOCOLATE" was a strapline which had been used in various UK media including TV, radio, magazines and posters without complaint continuously since 1991.  They stated that the strapline was registered as a trade mark with the UK Intellectual Property Office in 1999 and submitted a copy of the registration.  Mars pointed out that, under the transitional provisions of the Regulation, products bearing trade marks or brand names existing before 1 January 2005 which did not comply with the Regulation could continue to be marketed until 19 January 2022, after which time the Regulation would apply.  They said the Food Standards Agency Guidance to Compliance with the Regulation confirmed that the transition period applied to the trade mark, not the product.  They argued that, because the strapline "THE LIGHTER WAY TO ENJOY CHOCOLATE" was a trade mark that had existed and had been used in association with Maltesers since well before January 2005, its use in advertising could not currently be in breach of the Regulation, even if it was held to be a nutrition claim.

This advert was partially upheled because of the claim 'under 11 calories'.
"We considered the claim "less than 11 calories each", particularly in an ad that emphasised Maltesers not being as "naughty" as one woman had supposed, was likely to suggest to viewers that a Malteser was low in calories; we therefore considered it was a 'low energy' claim.  We understood that, because Maltesers contained 505 calories per 100 g, a 'low energy' claim should not have been made."


Upheld;

Asda advertisement.

A TV ad, for ASDA Stores Ltd (ASDA), showed a range of toys next to a banner that stated “1/2 PRICE TOYS”. The voiceover said "The only serious thing in ASDA's Toy Event are the prices! Everything is at least half price! This doll's house is loads of fun. This guitar and amp, now £60. And this Toy Story Ride On, half price at £15. Pick up some great savings in our biggest toy event this year. ASDA. Saving you money every day." On-screen text throughout most of the ad stated "Majority of Stores. Subject to Availability. Furniture with Doll's House sold separately."

The issue that people complained about was; Sainsbury's Supermarkets Ltd and a member of the public challenged whether the ad was misleading because they understood that the promotion applied only to selected items.

ASDA Stores Ltd (ASDA) said that the half-price toys event involved a limited but reasonable number of toys. They said that all of the toys featured in the ad were at half price or less and they believed that it was clear that the half price related only to toys in the Toy Event. They said that they did not think the average consumer would believe that that applied to every toy in their stores. They said that if all toys were in the sale they would not have referenced the Toy Event or restricted the toys featured in the ad to those selected. They provided a spreadsheet which indicated that the 17 products featured in the ad were all included in the sale.

The assemement from the ASA;

The ASA noted ASDA and Clearcasts view that the claim "The only serious thing in ASDA's Toy Event are the prices! Everything is at least half price!" would be interpreted to mean that only the toys included in the Toy Event sale were on sale for at least half price. However, we considered that the overall impression of the ad was that the toys featured were only a selection of the toys included in the "Toy Event" sale, and that, in conjunction with the claims "Everything is at least half price!" and "our biggest toy event this year", it was likely that viewers would infer that all toys were included in the sale. We concluded that, in the absence of a qualifying statement, the ad was misleading.

The overall action was that the advert must not be broadcasted again.

No comments:

Post a Comment